The following sheets; Experiment 1_Solution Rates, Experiment 2_Solution Rates, and Experiment 3_Solution Rates provide the mean percentage solution rate according to each condition. The following sheets; Experiment 1_Solution Strategy and Experiment 3_Solution Strategy provide the raw self-reported solution strategy score for each participant per condition. The raw scores varied from 1 to 4, where 1 indicated an analytic response, and 4 indicated an insight response. The highlighted yellow cells indicate a blank cell (where no CRAT was solved correctly for that participant in that particular condition) replaced with the condition mean.